A subscription app · B2C · Alper's UA account
When a new ad keeps overspending its budget at the same cost, raise it fast
5x campaign budget in two weeks with falling cost per purchase
What they did
What happened
In their words
Creative Misfires, False Positives, and Meta's Auction Flaws — Alper Taner, Stealth-Mode App Studio
David Barnard… following the rules of thumb, but I don't know how you would divide it up, but maybe 80% of your growth team's efforts should be focused on testing and moving fast and all that stuff, but you want to leave 10% or 20% to be continually auditing your processes, continually auditing your data structures, continuing to audit your events, structures, and all of those processes that are in place to make sure that you don't end up in those situations.
Alper TanerYeah. Another example I just remembered is on the positive side of things, we were doing creative testing and then we did find the winner at the end, thanks to interpreting the output and iterating on those output. So, it actually works when you do the iteration and find more winners. And we were able to, I think 5X the campaign budget within two weeks with the same and even decreasing cost per purchase. And we were not applying 20% increase per day. If you see that your daily budget is 2K, but I'll go spend 3K and you get the same performance, I was like, "Let me handle the bid and budget for this campaign because I see something, I see something very unusual." And I was so excited about it that we literally went hockey stick and the cost per purchase literally on a downhill and that's like any UA manager's dream.
Alper TanerAnd in those cases, but also the budget at some point was spending the double of the daily budget, but it is no problem as long as you have the performance. And talking about as a problem, like there are also companies who put, let's say, our spend on a Sunday as a problem, but then again, it's just a fact. My approach is, "Okay, what do you do for it? Have you decreased the bids and the budgets? How did you try to overcome this 'problem'?" And …
Get tactics like this every Monday
New tactics from the week's founder interviews, each linked to where it was said.
More from this episode
- When an ad wins, change one thing at a time to learn why before making moreExpert says it creates more winners; seen a concept's third variant win after two flopped
- Track cost per new ad that beats your current ads, not how many you testExpert says fewer, better-reasoned tests beat 500-a-month volume; no numbers
- Plot each ad's total spend against its cost per result to see when to stopBad ads are often clear by ~$500; one account burned ~$90K on a $100+ CPI ad
- When one ad eats 90% of an ad set's budget, give the other ads their own ad setOther ads often 'bloom' once the dominant ad is removed
- Keep the US out of campaigns with smaller countries; group countries by cost or value
- Set a $1M daily budget on Meta, but cap total spend and bids to control itMore high-quality traffic at stable cost for some accounts; others got no or runaway delivery
- Bid differently by placement or age group when their results differ by 20%+
- Tell Meta a trial start is a trial, not a purchaseCost per trial down ~35% with the same ads and campaigns
- Use MMP data to compare ads, but switch channels off to see what they really add
- Check which competitor ads have the most versions and longest runs in Meta's ad library
Tags: meta, scaling, budget, creative-iteration