GTM Sauce

App Masters · 2026-11-17

This GLP-Tracker App Makes $200K MRR (Copy Their Paywall)

Steve P. Young (App Masters) tears down Shotsy, an indie GLP-1 shot tracker that Similarweb estimates at over $200K a month: seasonality (peaks Feb-March), audience (mostly women 25-44), a long personalizing onboarding quiz, social proof before the paywall, and a paywall whose default plans have no trial, with the 7-day trial behind a radio button. He adds results from App Masters clients (yearly no-trial sign-ups; $4,000 more from dropping the in-app trial for active users) and suggests in-app offers after engagement moments.

Play the episode

8 tactics

Shotsy · B2C · GLP-1 shot tracking app

Host says the paywall works really well; no numbers

Onboarding paywall shows a testimonial, then yearly and monthly plans with no trial; the yearly plan is bigger in size and text. A radio button (used since Apple stopped allowing trial toggles) switches to a screen with the 7-day free trial on the yearly plan (and apparently the monthly). Users ready to buy, such as those referred by a friend, subscribe straight away; most still pick the trial.

Unknownpaywallpricing
App Masters · 2026-11-17

A subscription app · B2C · App Masters client

People buy the yearly plan without a trial; faster purchase signals to Meta

Same paywall pattern as Shotsy: a yearly plan with no trial offered alongside a free-trial option. Direct subscribe events reach Facebook faster than trial-to-paid. Host suggests a custom Meta event that counts either a trial start or a subscription, and optimizing for it instead of the trial-start event.

Workedpaywallpaid-social
App Masters · 2026-11-17

A subscription app · B2C · host's own app

One testimonial worked a bit better than big numbers; no figures

Paywall shows a single testimonial rather than aggregate stats (ratings count, member count). Male users see a male testimonial, female users a female one, based on onboarding answers.

Workedpaywall
App Masters · 2026-11-17

Long onboarding quiz: GLP-1 status, medication, average dose, device type, shot frequency, height, weight, goal weight, how fast to change, side effects, goals. Between questions, screens say how the app will help, and a summary plays the user's info back with a plan. Collects segmentation data (e.g. already on GLP-1 vs not yet started) and primes users to feel the app is personalized.

Unknownonboarding
App Masters · 2026-11-17

Before the paywall: 'Shotsy is the only app built by real GLP-1 users', a social-proof screen ('over 48,000 five-star ratings, join over 1 million other Shotsy members', a style the host saw in Flo), then a screen contrasting what users get done with Shotsy vs without (where they are now vs where they can be). An in-onboarding review request is also shown.

Unknownonboardingpaywall
App Masters · 2026-11-17

Shotsy · B2C · GLP-1 shot tracking app

After the paywall: an encouragement screen ('You got this'), then 'Add your first shot', a 'You did it' celebration with small animations, and a second review request for users who skipped the first.

Unknownproduct-activation
App Masters · 2026-11-17

A subscription app · B2C · App Masters case study

$4,000 more revenue; fewer trial starts

Users who already declined the onboarding paywall (with trial) and are actively using the app see an in-app paywall without a trial.

Workedpaywallpricing
App Masters · 2026-11-17

Timo · mobile app

Led to higher engagement, per the founder; no numbers

Small animations on the 'you did it' completion screens.

Workedproduct-activationretention
App Masters · 2026-11-17

Numbers mentioned

WhoMetricValueContextWhen
ShotsyrevenueUSD 200K/month
estimate
'Over 200,000' a month for most of 2026, per Similarweb estimate4:56
Shotsyrevenue2,400 thousand per month (as heard; likely ~$240K)
estimate
Peak month, March 2026, per Similarweb; figure garbled in speech4:56
ShotsyrevenueUSD 2.4M/year
estimate
Similarweb figure for the last 12 months; unit not said (read as revenue, matching the teaser's 'over $2 million a year')3:03
ShotsyrevenueUSD 2M/year
estimate
Teaser: 'over $2 million a year'1:36
Shotsysharepredominantly female, mostly aged 25-44; 35-44 growing
estimate
Audience mix per Similarweb Audience Insights5:16
Shotsyrating48K five-star ratings
approximate
Social-proof claim shown in Shotsy onboarding: 'over 48,000 five-star ratings'8:35
Shotsyusers1M users
approximate
Social-proof claim shown in Shotsy onboarding: 'join over 1 million other Shotsy members'8:35
Developer from an older App Masters case studyrevenue+USD 4,000
approximate
Extra revenue in the no-trial segment (active in-app users shown a paywall without a trial) vs with trial; period not stated13:28