Practitioner pattern · David Barnard (RevenueCat)
Ask for a star rating during onboarding, before people really use the app
Low-quality apps reach 4.9 stars vs 4.5 for a carefully built app; ratings become a poor signal
What they did
What happened
In their words
The Bootstrapper's Path to $10M ARR – Andrew Maguire, Volo Ventures
Jacob EitingWould change the numbers drastically,
David BarnardRight? The fact that they're - Apps have been... I mean, I've had this question for a long time. Why are all these apps who seem really crappy? Why are they 4.9 stars? In the app that I've poured my heart into for a decade is 4.5 stars. And the answer is when you ask in onboarding and you prompt write, you just get a volume of people who just don't even care and hit the five star and hit submit. So unfortunately the star ratings are so gamed at this point that it's a very poor quality signal. The one interesting thing, I think Ariel from Apfigures was doing this. He devised some ratios of the star rating of written reviews. What number of one-star written reviews do you have compared to the number of five-star ratings? Because it's easy to get somebody to tap the litle five-star thing and hit submit.
David BarnardIt's a lot harder to get them to go actually say something good and meaningful about the product. That's game to some point too, where people are still buying reviews and things like that, but Apple's cracked down on that quite a bit. So it's harder and harder to actually fake their written reviews. So that may be a better signal quality adjustment is to look at written reviews and do some ratios there.
Get tactics like this every Monday
New tactics from the week's founder interviews, each linked to where it was said.
More from this episode
- Report a copycat's bought ratings to Apple with collected evidenceApple did nothing
- Drop cost limits on AI features and let venture money cover inference
- Borrow up to 80% of ad spend, repaid from each month's new usersUsed by Ladder; 10% yearly interest, no equity given up; only for big proven apps
- Skip venture money and put each year's profits back into the appFounder says it built an amazing business with ~12 people; no numbers
- Put $1,000 into UGC videos for a new vibe-coded app
- Build an in-house analytics tool that anyone can query in plain EnglishInvestor calls it ridiculously powerful; no numbers
Tags: app-store, ratings-prompt, review-gaming