Tolan · B2C · AI alien companion app
Start with a 7-day free trial, then tune trial length to limit AI costs
What they did
In their words
12 AI Growth Lessons for Subscription Apps – Phil Carter, Elemental Growth
Phil Carter… product that essentially has no underlying costs, but that's not the reality for most businesses. And so this is just another flavor of what we just talked about, which is in the same way that AI powered features probably belong in a higher price subscription tier, trial links and freemium product offerings need to be a little bit more conservative in a world where giving away AI features has significant cost ramifications for the business.
Phil CarterAnd so Tolan is an example of a company that started with a seven-day free trial and has adjusted its free trial length and its premium offering over time. There are plenty of examples of other companies that are opting for shorter trials or adjusting their freemium offering for the same reasons. You guys had in your latest state of subscription apps report this data point that called out that despite longer trials, trials as long as 14 to 30 days often performing better on conversion, the majority of companies are actually trending in the opposite direction toward shorter term trials.
Phil CarterAnd I suspect the reason for this, if you were to cut it for AI versus non-AI apps, I suspect this is being driven largely by AI apps that are shortening their trials out of necessity, because if you give away 30 days of free AI feature usage and you have whales racking up massive compute costs without paying you a dime and then they churn, then that's not a sustainable business.
Get tactics like this every Monday
New tactics from the week's founder interviews, each linked to where it was said.
More from this episode
- Quiz new users, match them to an AI friend, then start a voice chatAdvisor credits it as a big part of their success; no numbers
- Show a shareable card of how the AI character's personality maps to yoursAdvisor calls it a viral artifact people share; no numbers
- Target serious runners with training plans that adapt after every runWon the race-training niche; later bought by Strava
- Put a small always-visible widget or calendar reminder where users already workGuest now uses voice nearly as much as typing; no company numbers
- Ship many AI study features fast and show each one on TikTok and DiscordNo results shared
- Use AI tools to go from tens to 400+ ad concepts a month400+ concepts/month; said to lower CAC and speed up learning
- Film a real person once, then use AI for 30 languages and music variantsAdvisor's standing advice to clients; no numbers
- Show the AI background remover in the first 6 seconds of every adLower CAC, higher conversion; opened Mexico, Brazil and Indonesia
- Let the decks and sites users make get shared and show up in searchGrew with very little paid acquisition; valued at $2B+
- Use cheaper, faster AI models where the output is good enoughProfitable 6 months after launch; faster product and lower compute costs
- Get early-adopter creators to post tutorials and templates for your new AI featureDrove organic adoption of Notion AI and better new-user retention; no numbers
- Replace the hard paywall with a free plan plus a 7-day trial of the best version+75% LTV per user (other pricing changes made at the same time)
- Switch from a hard paywall to a free planSubscriber conversion fell 50%+; reverted after a couple of weeks
- Keep AI features in a pricier top plan; give basic users a taste
Tags: free-trial, trial-length, compute-costs