GTM Sauce

Paywalls and pricing

Free trial tactics

Trial length, trial reminders and removing trials: what subscription apps tested and how conversion changed. 111 tactics from 77 founder interviews.

Most founders made the free trial harder to skip and easier to trust: showing the paywall early in onboarding, requiring a trial before use, and adding screens that promise a reminder before billing. These changes brought several of the largest reported gains. Trial length and extra offers after someone closes the paywall gave mixed results, and a few teams found trials added no new payers or lowered lifetime value.

Summary written 2026-09-29 from the tactics below. Figures are as founders stated them.

What worked, most detailed first

Built With Science · B2C · science-based fitness coaching app

Annual picks rose from ~60% to 75-80%, with no price change

Before: monthly and annual shown side by side. Variant: only the annual plan shown up front, with a Blinkist-style timeline above it: Day 1 you get your personalized plan; Day 7 your plan adapts to you; Day 12, before the 14-day free trial ends, 'we'll send you a reminder' and you can cancel anytime. Monthly is reachable via a 'view all plans' link. Price and positioning unchanged; UI-only change.

Workedpaywallpricing
Sub Club by RevenueCat · 2026-09-02

Practitioner pattern · Nick Godwin (Works at Superwall, the paywall platform demoed and recommended)

~11% pick the paid trial; first purchases jump; fails if priced $2.99 or less

'Design your trial' soft paywall: two annual plans with different App Store Connect introductory offers, so the choice is the trial, not the plan length. Option A: free trial (3 or 7 days). Option B: 30-day pay-up-front intro offer at $3.99-$5.99 (seen $7.99 work; $2.99 or lower fails). CTA text changes with the selection ('Redeem 3 days for $0' / '30 days for $4.99'); show the renewal annual price (even in the plan selectors, performs just as well); update the timeline for the paid trial; still send a reminder near day 28. Often combined with the multi-page paywall.

Workedpaywallpricing
App Masters · 2026-08-22

A subscription app · B2C · App Masters community member

Conversion 19% to 25%; proceeds up 21%

Two yearly options on the paywall: yearly at $59.99 with a 7-day free trial, and a paid intro offer of $1.99 for the first 30 days that renews at the $59.99 yearly price, replacing the monthly plan. Steve says it works well for most clients; Resumee uses it too.

Workedpricingpaywall
App Masters · 2026-05-23

Pingo AI · B2C · AI language speaking app

Beat social-proof and yearly-vs-monthly paywall versions; no numbers given

Multi-page paywall; first pages constant ('Learn to speak a new language with Pingo. We'll remind you 2 days before your trial ends' + timeline). Test page copy that won: 'Today, you unlock Pingo. In 5 days, you get a reminder and you'll be charged, and try it for free', annual shown with a weekly equivalent. Lost to it: 'Join over 3 million learners' with a real review, ratings and 'No commitment. Cancel anytime'; and a monthly-vs-yearly side-by-side. Intro-offer version: 'one-time offer for 55% off' with the same trial timeline beat the old 'one-time offer' page. Idea borrowed from a Superwall podcast.

Workedpaywall
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-04-20

Sunflower · B2C · addiction recovery app

+48% revenue, +70% annual revenue, +46% trial conversions, +30% trial starts

A/B tested a priming screen right before the paywall with the mascot bee: 'We want you to try Sunflower for free. We'll remind you before your trial ends,' then shows the paywall. Addresses trial anxiety. Tested a couple of versions of the screen.

Workedpaywallonboarding
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-04-03

A subscription apps · B2C · App Masters' own apps

Trial starts up 56% on one app; up to +100% on others. Weaker on a 3-day weekly plan

Copied from ReciMe. At the end of onboarding: a feature video, then screen 1 'We offer 7 days for free', screen 2 'You'll get a reminder 2 days before your trial ends', then the push-notification permission prompt, then the paywall. Best with a yearly plan defaulted with a 7-day trial; tried on a weekly plan with a 3-day trial and it worked less well.

Workedpaywallonboarding
App Masters · 2026-02-28

Momego · B2C · live bus and train times app

Paid conversion after closing the paywall rose from 0.4% to 4.5%

Anyone who dismisses the onboarding paywall still gets 7 days of premium (widgets, live activities, delay alerts). A post-onboarding flow lets them customize notifications and theme, and a Pro button (top right) offers video tutorials. Day 5: push 'you're on day five of your 7-day trial, tap to learn about the features'. Day 7: final push with a discount (on annual). Works because costs are mostly fixed servers; AI apps with per-user costs may prefer ads to cover free users.

Workedpaywallnotifications
App Masters · 2026-01-24

Duolingo · B2C · language learning app

Won A/B tests by easing fear of subscription traps

Purchase pages explain the mechanics: 'this is a seven day free trial; on day five we'll send you a notification to see if you still want your subscription.'

Workedpaywall
Sub Club by RevenueCat · 2026-01-21

Duolingo · B2C · language learning app

Beat 'Try for free' on both trial starts and trial-to-paid

Iterated purchase button copy in A/B tests: 'Subscribe' (baseline) -> 'Start my free trial' (big uplift) -> 'Try for free' (better) -> 'Try for $0.00' (best; believed live). Part of ~400 concurrent A/B tests, many on the purchase flow.

Workedpaywallexperimentation
Sub Club by RevenueCat · 2026-01-21

Elephas · B2C · AI assistant for Mac

$0 to $3K MRR in 6 months; feedback shaped the main feature

Each post centers on a video demo of one feature, wrapped in a problem-solution or story frame: 'me or my friend was facing this problem, so I built this feature to solve it. See, this is how it works. If you want to try, you can try it for 30 days for free. I'm just looking for feedback...'. Show, don't tell; explain the reasoning like talking to adults, no blatant self-promotion. Used to test the new Super Brain feature, whose feedback and feature requests made it the primary feature. Expect hate and bans; keep backup accounts and develop thick skin.

Workedcommunityvalidation
Starter Story · 2026-01-19

Claim · B2C · class action settlement finder app

34% trial start rate; multi-step paywalls lift conversion 20-40% vs one screen

3-screen paywall for a 3-day trial. Screen 1: 'We want you to try Claim for free', with visuals of settlements you could claim. Screen 2: 'We'll send you a reminder before your trial ends', button 'Try for $0'. Screen 3 (main): repeats the reminder, shows a today / reminder / billing timeline, a 'free trial' badge on the plan card. The annual plan is not called annual: the card says 'Try it free' and shows '$59.99 per year, only $1 per week'; the CTA says 'Try for free'. The trial length appears only in the timeline, not on the plan card, to avoid 'I must remember to cancel in 3 days' anxiety. Free is mentioned 5-7 times in total.

Gray hatWorkedpaywall
The Superwall Podcast · 2025-12-16

Opal · B2C · screen time app

Near zero to $5M ARR in about a year, no separate marketing budget

Paid ads (with a paywall and RevenueCat) from the first week on the App Store to get a steady ~100 downloads a day. Dropped other goals and focused on one metric: Day 8 ROAS, chosen because the 7-day free trial converts by day 8, so a change shipped Monday is readable 8 days later. Tested with small spend until there was a path to 100%, then scaled. Every week review last week's D8 ROAS: above 100% expand budgets, below 100% cut back until back at 100%. No growth target or marketing budget: revenue reinvested on the 8-day cycle. Started with simple spend this week vs revenue 8 days later; moved to install-week cohorts (D8 and D30) once late conversions skewed numbers.

Workedpaid-socialanalytics-attribution
Sub Club by RevenueCat · 2024-01-10

What didn't work, or only partly

Companies in this topic

Benchmarks

More tactics (90)

New tactics every Monday

The week's founder interviews, boiled down to what they did and what happened.

Related topics