Paywalls and pricing
Upsell tactics
Upgrades, add-ons, consumables and bundles that raised revenue per user. 71 tactics from 37 founder interviews.
Most teams added a second way to pay on top of the subscription: credits or packs for heavy users, a one-time offer at the moment of purchase, higher tiers, or live and physical extras. Where numbers were given, upsells usually reached about 5-20% of buyers or revenue, though two meditation apps grew far more by selling live sessions. New premium tiers and standalone features sometimes found few takers or pulled buyers from the main plan.
- Sway AI said extra profile analyses brought about 11% of revenue and AI photo packs were its biggest upsell; Shipper's credit top-ups made about 10% of revenue, and Burner's credit top-ups about 8-10%.Sway AI (1)Sway AI (2)ShipperBurner
- Well-timed offers converted: Reading.com's $9.99 all-worksheets offer right after purchase was taken by about 20% of web buyers, Architectural Digest's business-membership pop-up by about 5%, and Mojo's weekly paywall for free users brought 15% of new revenue.Reading.comArchitectural DigestMojo
- Brightmind added coaching, online events and retreats and reported revenue up 50%; another struggling meditation app sold classes, intensives and Zoom sessions and said revenue almost doubled, with live offers now half of it.BrightmindA meditation app
- At Tinder, a guest called moving from one tier to three, with consumables on top, his biggest revenue unlock, and Super Like recipients are three times as likely to match; Burner called its unlimited plan among its biggest revenue jumps.Tinder (1)Tinder (2)Burner
- Some upsells missed: Condé Nast's premium tiers stalled at 1-2% adoption, Duolingo's on-demand human tutor tier failed because users found live speaking too scary, and Super Unlimited's eSIM ad to all its VPN users drew few buyers.Condé NastDuolingoSuper Unlimited
- Selling features separately cut both ways: Tinder's standalone travel pass sent conversion up but pulled buyers from its cheapest plan, even after repricing, while Burner, which phased out credits for subscriptions, now suspects credits suited short-term users better.Tinder (1)Tinder (2)Burner
Summary written 2026-09-26 from the tactics below. Figures are as founders stated them.
What worked, with the best evidence
What didn't work, or only partly
- Practice by Numbers: Call existing customers to switch their card payments to you for a cut~$190M processed of ~$2B possible; profitable but switching is hard
- Condé Nast: Launch new premium tiers for fans willing to pay moreAdoption stuck at 1-2%; now default no unless a bigger cohort is proven
- Tinder: Price the 7-day feature pass the same as a 7-day subscription, shown side by sideLess cannibalization and more revenue, but still not good enough
- Super Unlimited: Show an ad for your new eSIM app to all existing VPN usersDidn't work: no travel intent; now planning timed promos before summer
- Tinder: Sell the travel feature on its own for 1 day, 3 days or a weekConversion jumped, but it pulled buyers away from the cheapest subscription
- Duolingo: Offer live human tutors on demand in a higher-priced planFailed: users joined, panicked and left; later replaced by AI video call
- Burner: Phase out one-off credits so everyone goes through a subscriptionFairly high churn from short-term users; founder now thinks credits might have fit them better
- Include credits in the subscription and let heavy users buy moreSpreading, e.g. 13% of photo/video apps; too few included credits drew angry reviews
- Tinder: Show ads to free users to cover their costSmall share of revenue; ads worth far less than a subscriber
Companies in this topic
More tactics (50)
- Fleet: Sell a paid add-on to secure and remotely manage rented laptops~EUR 1M ARR, a small slice of total revenue
- Sway AI: Sell AI photo packs at $14.99 for one and $49.99 for tenBiggest upsell in the app; no spending cap lets big spenders pay more
- Mail-Lead: Put an 'automation' button in the side tool that opens your paid main productFounder says it drove paid users into the main product; no separate numbers
- Duolingo: Give 3 free days of the paid tier, no card needed, even to current subscribersEffective for free-to-paid and for upgrading subscribers to the top tier, per guest
- Burner: Add a monthly and annual plan with unlimited texts, calls and photosBiggest single jump in revenue in company history; subscriptions now 90%+ of revenue
- Tinder: Offer three subscription levels and sell extra boosts on topFormer CPO calls it one of the best ways to price consumer apps; no revenue split given
- Simply: Sell a bundle of all your apps on the web, where you can explain itGuest says it works well; no numbers
- Life360: Sell trackers at low margins to pull people into the app and keep them longerTile owners retain better than non-owners; Pet GPS requires a subscription
- Super Unlimited: Charge for no ads, faster servers, more locations and use on every deviceCompany growing and very profitable; no conversion numbers
- Ladder: Add nutrition tracking to a workout app after users asked for it in the surveyEarly read: users doing both convert and stay much more; no numbers yet
- Duolingo: When users run out of hearts, offer a free trial so they keep their lesson progressUsers much more likely to start a trial; no numbers
- Duolingo: Give users one free AI video call from the top tierEffective lever for getting people to try the feature, per guest
- Duolingo: Use each user's signals to pick between your own upgrade ads and paid adsGood wins, per guest; no numbers
- Duolingo: Let a bandit algorithm pick which upgrade ad each user sees after a lessonSome wins so far, still improving; no numbers
- Skylight: Knock money off the device when people buy it with the subscriptionMuch higher subscription attach on the own website than on Amazon or in stores; no numbers
- Tinder: Offer several paid tiers, from cheap starter to big spenders at $50K a yearGuest's biggest revenue unlock at Tinder; no numbers given
- Burner: Add caller lookup for unknown numbers to the premium planVery popular and a driver of premium upsells; founder didn't expect it to win
- Burner: Add a white-label VPN inside the main app's premium planDrove a lot of premium-tier growth, but cost more to build than it should have
- The Washington Post: Pair the news subscription with coffee: cafe access and branded coffee beansGuest cites press and business results; no numbers
- Add in-app coins that people earn from ads or buy in packsApps that crack consumables reach deeper LTVs, per talks with hundreds of founders
- On Android, let people buy one feature or one piece of contentGoogle reports much better Android monetization with hybrid models; no numbers given
- VueMagnet: Sell a pricier agency plan so agencies can manage many creators in one placeUnexpectedly became the main earner; most of the $6,500 in 60 days (implied)
- Life360: Offer a free Tile tracker to people who subscribeHelps conversion for certain users; no numbers
- Sunflower: Build everything around the one simple thing users do every dayTimer is the most important feature; AI chat alone had poor retention
- Super Unlimited: Launch a Windows version and promote it to your mobile usersNamed biggest win of the year; people buy on the website directly, no numbers
- The Washington Post: Bundle the news subscription with Headspace for readers overwhelmed by newsGuest cites business results but warns partnerships are very hard
- Slopes: Sell day and season passes next to the subscription for occasional usersHost cites it as working; no numbers
- Sell a $1 plan after a 60-question quiz, then stack add-ons to ~$350Buyer got half back after demanding a refund; invites regulation
- Duolingo: Give the free 3 days as a reward right after a finished lessonFelt more rewarding than on the learning path; no numbers
- Duolingo: Use the end-of-lesson ad slot to advertise your own paid planGuest says house ads beat programmatic ads; no numbers
- Tinder: Interview users spending $100-250 a month, then build a top plan for themLed to Tinder Platinum; no results shared
- Swipe.by: Give websites and online ordering away free; charge for the AI services on top
- Savvy Navvy: Include 12 months of the app with new boats, paid for by the boat makerFounder says it feeds a consumer-to-manufacturer flywheel; no numbers
- Simply Piano: Mark songs in the piano app that you can also sing in the singing app
- GlamUp: Limit scans per week by plan, and offer a bigger plan when they run out
- LeadQuest: Add a lead-finding tool so users then need your email and automation toolsFounder says the products help each other; no numbers for the lead tool
- Mindfulness App: Sell the app to employers, using stress tests to prove it lowers staff stress
- Strava: Buy a beginner-friendly app and sell it to your users as a bundleDeal closed; adviser calls it '1+1=6'; no post-deal numbers shared
- Wired: Make editor Q&A sessions subscriber-only and add them to the subscription
- Plarium: Sell mugs, t-shirts and hoodies to a game's biggest spenders
- Sell $5-10 top-up credits on top of subscription tiers
- Reading.com: Sell printed sets of the app's storybooks on Amazon
- Handwrytten: Let customers add gift cards or cookies to each note
- Lose It!: Add ads to the free app, one-off purchases, and affiliate partner deals
- Grindr: Add a several-hundred-dollar monthly AI tier that does the swiping and matching
- Ad Hoc Labs: Buy small apps that fit your users' needs and sell them inside your main app
- Vogue: Offer everything from a free app to pricey white-glove in-person experiences
- Soundmap: Sell power-ups on top of the subscription, like 2x more songs nearbyGuest says it captures what each user is willing to spend; no numbers
- Strava: Keep a bought app separate and sell one subscription for both apps
- Clear 30: Offer the app to universities and addiction services, and add paid extras
New tactics every Monday
The week's founder interviews, boiled down to what they did and what happened.