GTM Sauce

Getting users

Instagram marketing tactics

Instagram Reels, accounts, creators and ads: tactics app founders used on Instagram and what came of them. 312 tactics from 105 founder interviews.

Most apps grew on Instagram through short videos made by paid creators or founders, often the same formats posted to TikTok and Reels, with creator networks reaching hundreds of millions of views. Views did not always turn into downloads: novelty and hook-only formats drew huge reach but converted poorly, while videos demoing the app tended to convert better.

Summary written 2026-09-28 from the tactics below. Figures are as founders stated them.

What worked, most detailed first

Jetpack · B2C · flight savings app

Agency says it now knows exactly which organic videos drive App Store traffic; no numbers

Register a benefit-named domain used only in the agency's organic videos (flightcheatcode.com for Jetpack; buyabusiness.com / buythebusinessyouwant.com for SMB Market) that redirects straight to the app/App Store. Separates organic creator traffic from paid ads, other agencies and in-house creators running at the same time, and is easier to remember than an unknown brand name. Used only for brands without a well-known or viral name (not needed for e.g. Polymarket). Tested on a couple of apps; SMB Market's domain went live a few weeks before the episode.

Workedanalytics-attributionugc-creators
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-10-07

Dupe.com · B2C · shopping app for cheaper lookalikes

Usually yields a 500K-1M-view video within 4-5 days

When a creator video reaches 10-20K views with at least 3% engagement, tell the creator to double down: repost the exact same video a few more times, and/or reshoot it in the same kitchen with the same script, changing only the spoken hook and text hook. Keep going while the reposts clear 10K views. Rationale: comparable videos differ mostly by timing and volume (Marilyn's 6.9M-view video was no better than a sibling video from another creator).

Workedugc-creatorscreator-ops
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-10-07

Cal AI · B2C · photo calorie tracking app

Guaranteed a profitable CPM on every deal; creators couldn't back down

When a creator says they can 'easily get a million views', agree and add a minimum view clause a couple hundred thousand below that (e.g. 800K, or 700K after checking their page), framed as 'just for our safety' and 'so it's not stressful for you'. Payment is tied to hitting the floor each month. Check their actual numbers first so the floor is realistic and hit every month.

Workedinfluencercreator-ops
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-08-26

Practitioner pattern · Nick Lawton (co-founder of SideShift, the UGC creator platform and paid-ads integration he recommends)

Called the most fruitful structure for creators seen on the platform

First month budget $2-4K. Each creator gets a guaranteed base retainer of $600-800 for 30-60 videos (roughly daily or twice-daily posts) plus a $1-2 CPM view bonus. Leave the bonus uncapped so viral videos pay off, or cap it to guarantee profitability. The single goal of month one is finding content-market fit.

Workedcreator-opsugc-creators
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-08-06

Pep AI · B2C · peptide and GLP-1 tracker

Core of the creator program behind most revenue

Trial month: 1 feed video + 1 story per week (4 videos, 4 stories) plus tracked link in bio for the whole month, including TikTok stories. Price on average views/engagement, not followers: ~5,000 views/video -> ~$200 for the month; bigger creators up to $4,000/month. After the month, raise/keep/lower pay based on the creator's tracked signups; strong performers go straight to a 3-month deal.

Workedinfluencercreator-ops
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-07-01

Pep AI · B2C · peptide and GLP-1 tracker

Signs many creators every week; delegating made it scale

4 dedicated outreach hires plus the team send the same DM on TikTok and Instagram (100+/day, 1,000+/week). First line: 'Paid promo / affiliate deal?' then a short app pitch and fit with their content. On reply, ask for their number, move to WhatsApp/iMessage and call immediately. Two marketing managers (friends trained by the founder on his own playbook) run calls, deals, contracts, payment, code/link setup and the video guide; founder takes calls with bigger creators. Outreach hires are briefed on exactly which creators to target.

Workedcreator-opsteam-process
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-07-01

The Evolved Founder · B2B · coaching for startup founders

Winning hook hit ~50K views vs 500; ~3,000 new followers in a day

Posts the same video with different hooks as Instagram Trial Reels, which show only to non-followers. Lets them run a few hours, then promotes the best-performing version to the main feed, and keeps the losing version up in trial reels because it keeps reaching non-followers. Hook drives watch-through. Winning hook opened a question ('Raise VC money. You can make $50 million and still be broke') while the loser answered it ('I teach people how to fundraise, but I wouldn't raise a single dollar today').

Workedorganic-short-videofounder-brand
App Masters · 2026-06-20

Locked · B2C · gamified self-improvement to-do app

3-4% reply rate on Instagram, ~2% on TikTok; 5-10K creators contacted

Search Instagram/TikTok for niche terms (gym, self-improvement, day in the life), open each creator profile, paste the template DM, send, repeat. Each account hits a rate limit around 100 DMs/day, so run multiple sender accounts; buy 1,000+ followers for each and get it verified so it looks legitimate. Team sent 500+ DMs/day at peak; 5,000-10,000+ creators contacted in total.

Black hatWorkedinfluencercreator-ops
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-06-11

Locked · B2C · gamified self-improvement to-do app

Founder says it stands out in flooded inboxes; no numbers

Message opens with 'Paid promo?' so it stands out among hundreds of DMs, then: 'Hey, I'm the founder of Locked. We're looking to partner with a select group of day in the life or self-improvement creators. Would you be down to hop on a call and discuss a deal?' When creators suggest DMs, push for a call; almost never negotiate over DMs.

Workedinfluencercreator-ops
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-06-11

Locked · B2C · gamified self-improvement to-do app

Founder says curious viewers find the app through it; no numbers

Because Instagram can't carry a trackable link, the founder (or a personal account) comments something like 'I need this. What's the app called?'; the creator replies with the app name and pins the comment so curious viewers see it at the top of the comments.

Workedinfluencer
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-06-11

StudyFetch · B2C · AI study app for students

Standard terms for a program of hundreds of creators (peak ~1,000)

Base rate per video historically $50-2,500 depending on talent (great creators get high base even without an audience). Bonus: $100 per 100,000 views on TikTok or Instagram. Individual deals may raise or lower either part. Roster size flexes with goals: up to ~1,000 creators when chasing views, a smaller group when chasing high-converting content for a specific audience.

Workedcreator-opsugc-creators
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-05-26

Sprout · B2C · swipe-to-apply job search app

Hundreds of millions of views and many conversions (not attributable)

Faceless 6.7-second video: text 'War is over. Finally landed my first full-time job' over a Google Sheet job tracker; a dropdown is switched to 'Accepted'. Length tested at 5, 6 and 7 seconds; 6.7s won. Filmed at a tilted (not 90-degree) angle; show the sheet, zoom in, click the dropdown slowly so options are visible but not clear, click Accepted, zoom again, zoom out. Creators get ready-made Google Sheet templates and a tutorial video.

Workedorganic-short-videougc-creators
The Superwall Podcast · 2026-05-13

What didn't work, or only partly

Companies in this topic

More tactics (271)

New tactics every Monday

The week's founder interviews, boiled down to what they did and what happened.

Related topics